Mrs. Waldo Richards's 1918 anthology The Melody of Earth collects garden and nature poems by poets active at the time of its publication. The compiler's foreword frames the collection as a response to “the world's travail,” offering readers a retreat into cultivated nature. The poems range from earnest reflections on labor and growth—as in Edgar A. Guest's “Results and Roses,” which insists “You've got to dig from week to week / To get Results or Roses”—to playful personifications such as Oliver Herford's “Tell-Tale,” where a lily, rose, and tulip gossip about each other's appearances. The anthology also includes dialect poems, like T. A. Daly's “Da Thief,” written in an Italian-accented English, which recounts stealing a rose for a tired wife.

Contrasting Tones: Earnestness and Whimsy

The anthology juxtaposes poems with markedly different registers. Alongside Guest's didactic couplets on the necessity of digging, readers find Herford's satirical flower dialogue, where the lily accuses the rose of painting her color. This tonal range extends to L. H. Bailey's “Miracle,” a short lyric marveling at bud emergence (“Yesterday the twig was brown and bare; / To-day the glint of green is there”), and to the anonymous “The Awakening,” which treats the same phenomenon with religious intensity: “So doth God's rapture rend the tomb / In this wee burst of April green!” The compiler does not segregate these voices; instead, they appear side by side, inviting readers to move between reverence and humor.

Dialect and the Persona of the Gardener

Several poems adopt non-standard English to create distinct speaker personae. Daly's “Da Thief” uses a phonetic Italian accent to tell of a laborer who steals a rose for his wife, ending with the defiant claim “Eef 'thief's' my name I feel no shame.” The poem's dialect marks the speaker as an outsider, yet his act of theft is portrayed as loving and justified. Similarly, James Whitcomb Riley's “Thoughts fer the Discuraged Farmer” (included in the anthology, though not excerpted here) would employ Hoosier dialect to address agricultural hardship. These dialect poems contrast with the formal, elevated language of poems like Helen Hay Whitney's sonnet, which speaks of “crimson secret” and “everlasting light.” The anthology thus presents multiple social registers of nature experience.

Recurring Motifs: Labor, Growth, and the Senses

Two motifs recur across the selections: the physical work of gardening and the sensory delight of nature. Guest's poem explicitly links results to digging, while “The Awakening” describes buds as “jets of sweet desire / In upward curling threads of fire.” The sense of smell is particularly emphasized: in “Da Thief,” the rose's scent “maka heaven een my nose,” and the foreword speaks of “subtle melodies” and “secret voices” that only poets hear. The anthology's structure—grouping poems by theme or mood, though not explicitly labeled—allows these motifs to echo across different authors. Readers will notice how often the poems return to the moment of emergence, whether of a leaf, a flower, or a feeling of hope.

Readers approaching The Melody of Earth should attend to the variety of poetic forms and voices gathered here. The anthology rewards browsing: a sonnet may follow a dialect monologue, and a lighthearted fable may precede a solemn meditation. The compiler's principle of selection—favoring poems that find “melody” in nature—means that even the most whimsical pieces participate in a larger argument about the restorative power of the natural world. This is a collection to be dipped into, not read straight through, and its pleasures lie in the contrasts between neighboring poems.